SoundMasker

Home / Guides / Sound masking / Speech intelligibility

The measurements, plainly

Speech intelligibility and how privacy is measured

Speech privacy has numbers behind it, and they appear in specifications, test reports, and vendor claims without much explanation. This page sets out what Articulation Index and Privacy Index are, where the thresholds sit, and what a measurement does and does not tell you. It is the reference the rest of these pages point back to.

1

The numbers, without a sales pitch

What AI and PI mean, which standard defines them, and where the accepted thresholds are. No product is being recommended on this page.

2

Enough to read a report

Test reports and specifications assume you know these terms. A page of reading is the difference between checking a claim and taking it on faith.

3

Check a claim before you sign

A specification promising confidential privacy is making a measurable claim. These are the numbers that decide whether it was met.

How to read the numbers

  1. Find the Articulation Index in the report or specification. At or below 0.05 is confidential, 0.05 to 0.20 is normal office privacy.
  2. Check which standard was used. For an open plan, ASTM E1130 is the one that matters.
  3. Ask how many points in each zone were measured, and whether the space was occupied or empty when they were taken.
  4. Ask for the same measurement after commissioning, not only a prediction from the design stage. The two are often different.
Where to put the speaker: speech intelligibility

Intelligibility is a ratio, not a volume

Whether you can understand someone depends on how far their voice rises above the background, frequency band by frequency band, across the range where speech carries meaning. That is why a library is a privacy problem and a busy cafe is not. The cafe is far louder, and far more private.

Masking works on the bottom half of that ratio. Raising the background by a few decibels in the speech band drops intelligibility sharply without making the room feel loud. Absorption and barriers work on the top half, by reducing how much of the voice arrives in the first place.

Intelligibility is a ratio, not a volume

Articulation Index and Privacy Index

Articulation Index, usually written AI, is a number from 0 to 1 describing how much of speech is intelligible to a listener. Privacy Index is its complement expressed as a percentage: PI = 100 x (1 - AI). One is the mirror of the other, and vendors tend to quote whichever sounds better.

The thresholds in common use: AI at or below 0.05, which is PI of 95% or more, is treated as confidential privacy, where words cannot be made out. AI between about 0.05 and 0.20, or PI of 80% to 95%, is normal privacy, where speech is audible but takes effort to follow and is not distracting. Above roughly AI 0.20 speech becomes both intelligible and distracting.

ASTM E1130 is the standard test method for measuring speech privacy objectively in open-plan spaces using this approach. If a report cites a privacy figure without a method, the method is the first thing to ask about.

What the measurement does not tell you

A privacy number is measured between two specific points at one moment, with assumptions about how loudly the talker speaks. Move the listener, raise a voice, or close a door and the number changes. A single figure for a whole floor is an average with real variation inside it.

It also says nothing about comfort. A space can measure as confidential and still be unpleasant, if the masking is uneven between zones, too bright in the high frequencies, or sitting on top of a reverberant room that needed absorption first.

The other ratings you will meet

STC, Sound Transmission Class, rates how much sound a wall assembly blocks. It applies to closed rooms, and a wall that stops at the suspended ceiling rather than continuing to the deck will underperform its rating badly.

NRC, Noise Reduction Coefficient, rates how much sound a surface absorbs, which is what keeps a room from ringing. CAC, Ceiling Attenuation Class, rates how much sound passes between two closed rooms through the shared space above the ceiling, and it is the number most often forgotten when private offices turn out not to be private.

What you need

  • A sound level meter app, for rough levels rather than compliance
  • A colleague willing to talk from the next room
  • The floor plan, if you want to know where the problem points are

Mistakes to avoid

  • Treating a single privacy figure as true everywhere on a floor
  • Accepting a privacy claim with no test method named
  • Assuming a high STC wall gives privacy when it stops at the ceiling grid
  • Reading a phone app as a calibrated measurement

Questions

What is speech intelligibility?

How much of what someone says can be understood by a listener. It depends on the ratio between the voice and the background sound across the frequencies where speech carries meaning, not on the volume of either alone.

What is the Articulation Index?

A score from 0 to 1 for how intelligible speech is. At or below 0.05 words cannot be made out, which is treated as confidential privacy. Between 0.05 and 0.20 speech is audible but hard to follow.

What is the Privacy Index?

The complement of the Articulation Index as a percentage: PI = 100 x (1 - AI). A Privacy Index of 95% or more is confidential; 80% to 95% is normal privacy.

How is speech privacy measured?

ASTM E1130 is the standard method for open-plan spaces. It compares a measured speech spectrum against the measured background in each band to produce an Articulation Index between two points.

Why is a quiet office less private than a loud one?

Because privacy depends on the ratio of voice to background, not on how quiet the room is. A quiet room lets a voice from thirty feet away arrive clearly above the background.

Get it quoted

Tell us about the space and we will pass it to as many installers in your area as we can, so you get real quotes to compare. They survey it, fit the system, and tune it. Free, and nothing to pay at any point.

Related